A Stoic Response to Blumenthal's Critique of Hegseth

In the article, Sidney Blumenthal critiques Pete Hegseth's controversial actions and statements regarding military conduct and war crimes, focusing on his self-proclaimed title of "Secretary of War" and his apparent disregard for military legal standards. Blumenthal argues that Hegseth's actions, including a reported drone strike order that led to civilian casualties, reflect a troubling lack of accountability in warfare. He claims that Hegseth's disdain for military ethics and his advocacy for pardoning convicted war criminals exemplify a dangerous mindset that undermines the moral fabric of the U.S. military.

Main Argument Restated

Blumenthal's central thesis is that Hegseth embodies a "warrior ethos" that prioritizes violence over ethical considerations, as evidenced by his flippant orders and dismissive attitude toward military law. He highlights a specific quote from Hegseth: “You’re either on the team or you’re not. When you get an order, you move out fast and don’t ask questions.” This perspective raises profound ethical questions about leadership in military contexts and the implications of such a mindset for the broader society.

Stoic Perspective on Accountability and Virtue

From a Stoic viewpoint, virtue is the highest good, and it encompasses wisdom, justice, courage, and moderation. Hegseth's actions starkly contrast with Stoic principles, particularly the notion of logos, or rational order. The Stoics teach that we must act in accordance with nature and reason, which includes recognizing the inherent dignity of all human beings—even in wartime.

• What is within our control: We cannot control the actions of others, but we can control our responses to those actions. Hegseth's disregard for ethical oversight cannot absolve us from our responsibility to demand accountability.
• Virtue as a guide: True leadership requires a commitment to justice and ethical behavior. Hegseth’s approach, which glorifies violence and undermines military law, is a betrayal of the very virtues that should guide military conduct.

Decisive Guidance

In light of Blumenthal's critique and the Stoic doctrines, consider these decisive instructions:

1. Demand Accountability: As citizens and leaders, we must advocate for transparency and justice in military actions. Silence in the face of wrongdoing is complicity.

2. Cultivate Inner Virtue: Reflect on your own values and actions. Strive to embody the Stoic virtues in your life, especially in challenging situations where ethical decisions are required.

3. Engage in Constructive Dialogue: Foster conversations about military ethics and accountability. Encourage a culture where questioning orders is seen as a duty, not a betrayal.

4. Educate Others: Share the principles of Stoicism and how they apply to contemporary issues of military ethics. Help others understand that true strength lies not in blind obedience but in moral courage.

By adhering to these Stoic principles, we can contribute to a more just and ethical discourse surrounding military conduct, ensuring that the values we hold dear are not lost in the fog of war.