A Stoic SaysA Stoic Says logo - Daily Stoic philosophy and wisdom

February 2, 2026

Where is the outrage over five-year-old Liam Ramos’s detention? | Francine Prose

In her article, Francine Prose highlights the shocking detention of five-year-old Liam Ramos by ICE agents, emphasizing the emotional and psychological trauma he endured while held in a facility for child detainees. Despite his family's pending asylum application and no criminal charges against them, Liam was taken from school and subjected to harsh conditions, prompting public outrage and intervention from congressional representatives. Prose argues that this incident reflects a broader issue of inhumanity within U.S. immigration policies and calls for a reevaluation of how vulnerable individuals, especially children, are treated. The case serves as a rallying point for advocates seeking to reform immigration practices and protect the rights of those fleeing persecution.

Thumbnail for Where is the outrage over five-year-old Liam Ramos’s detention? | Francine Prose

Stoic Response

Justice & RightsPolitics & GovernanceCulture & Identity

Citizens of the Agora,

Today, we gather in the spirit of justice and compassion, compelled by the harrowing tale of young Liam Ramos, a five-year-old boy whose innocence was shattered by the very institutions that should protect him. As Francine Prose poignantly illustrates, Liam was seized by ICE agents on his way home from school, torn from his family amidst a pending asylum application. This act, devoid of humane consideration, is a striking reminder of our collective responsibility to uphold the cardinal virtues of justice, courage, and compassion.

Liam’s story is not merely an isolated incident; it reflects a systematic failure that has left many vulnerable individuals, especially children, at the mercy of harsh immigration policies. Consider this: as of January 2026, reports indicate that over 2,000 children remain detained in facilities akin to prisons, where their basic needs for safety and emotional well-being are neglected. This is not just a statistic; these are lives—lives that deserve dignity and care, lives that reflect our shared humanity.

In the face of such inhumanity, we must summon our courage. The emotional and psychological trauma inflicted on Liam and countless others calls us to action. The words of federal judge Fred Biery resonate with us: our government must not surrender to "the perfidious lust for unbridled power." We must demand accountability and reform, ensuring that those who seek refuge from persecution are treated with the respect they deserve.

Let us not allow Liam’s suffering to be in vain. Instead, let it serve as a rallying point, a clarion call for all of us to advocate for change. Reach out to your representatives, join the protests, and lend your voice to the chorus demanding justice for those still trapped in the shadows of our immigration system.

As we stand here today, I charge each of you to embody the virtues of empathy and action. Let us be the guardians of humanity, ensuring that no child, no family, is left behind. Together, we can forge a society that reflects our highest ideals—one where compassion reigns, and every individual is treated with dignity. Stand with me, and let us reshape our future.

Article Rewritten Through Stoic Lens

A Stoic Reflection on the Case of Liam Ramos

In the face of adversity, we are often presented with opportunities to cultivate our character and demonstrate our virtues. The case of five-year-old Liam Ramos, detained by ICE agents, serves as a profound test of our collective virtue and humanity.

Wisdom: Understanding the Context

On January 20, 2026, Liam, a pre-K student, was taken from school in Columbia Heights, Minnesota, by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents. His family, having emigrated from Ecuador in 2024, had applied for political asylum. No deportation order existed against them, nor had they committed any crime. This incident raises critical questions about our immigration policies and the treatment of vulnerable individuals, particularly children.

As we reflect on this, we must seek to understand the broader implications of such actions. The detention of Liam and his father in a facility designed for child detainees highlights a systemic issue that demands our attention and introspection.

Courage: Facing Injustice with Resolve

Liam's experience in detention was marked by emotional and psychological trauma. Reports indicated he appeared pale, lethargic, and depressed, longing for his mother and friends. His situation drew the concern of Democratic representatives Joaquin Castro and Jasmine Crockett, who visited the Dilley facility and witnessed the conditions firsthand. Their courage to speak out against this injustice reflects the Stoic principle of standing firm in the face of wrongdoing.

The public outcry that followed, with hundreds demonstrating for Liam’s release, exemplifies the collective courage to confront inhumanity. It is a reminder that our virtues can shine brightly even in the darkest situations.

Justice: Advocating for the Vulnerable

Federal Judge Fred Biery ruled that Liam's detention was unconstitutional, stating that it stemmed from "ill-conceived and incompetently implemented daily deportation quotas." His ruling not only recognized the injustice faced by Liam but also highlighted the need for a reevaluation of immigration practices.

This case calls upon us to advocate for justice—not just for Liam, but for all children who find themselves in similar circumstances. The Stoic belief in justice compels us to protect the rights of the vulnerable and to ensure that no child is subjected to such trauma.

Temperance: Responding with Measured Gratitude

While the release of Liam and his father is a moment of relief, it is essential to approach this outcome with temperance. We must express gratitude for their freedom without becoming attached to the notion of victory. Instead, we should view this as an opportunity for reflection and growth.

The hope is that Liam's ordeal will inspire a significant rethinking of how we treat those seeking refuge in our country. It is a chance for us to cultivate empathy and compassion, recognizing that our responses to such events shape our character and the society we wish to build.

Conclusion: A Call to Virtue

The story of Liam Ramos is not merely a tale of suffering; it is a call to embody the cardinal virtues of wisdom, courage, justice, and temperance. As we navigate the complexities of immigration policy and human rights, let us remember that each conflict presents a test of our virtue.

May we strive to ensure that no child is subjected to such trauma again, and may we advocate for a system that reflects our highest ideals. In doing so, we honor not only Liam’s experience but also our shared humanity.

Source Body Text

Liam Conejo Ramos. We have all seen his picture, or by now we all should have seen the image of the adorable five-year-old in his bright blue hat, its floppy bunny ears so appropriate for a child whose middle name means “rabbit”. In the photo, he is wearing his Spider-Man backpack, which, like so many kids his age, he loves and is very proud of. And we know – or we should know – what happened to him. On 20 January 2026, the pre-K student was seized by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents on his way home from school in Columbia Heights, Minnesota. His family, which had emigrated from Ecuador in 2024, had applied for political asylum. No order of deportation had been issued against them, nor had any of them – obviously, not little Liam – been accused of a crime. He and his father, who had come to pick him up at school, were taken to Dilley, Texas, not far from San Antonio, where they were held in a facility that houses many child detainees. Unsurprisingly, Liam had a difficult time adjusting to life in prison. Visitors reported that he seemed pale, lethargic and depressed. A photo of him lying with his eyes closed in his father’s arms was immensely alarming. He had been sleeping a lot and – like many kids at the center – had trouble eating the vile prison food. He kept asking what happened to his blue cap and his Spider-Man backpack, which had been taken from him and not returned by ICE officers. He missed his mother, his classmates, his friends. He longed to be back in school. You can watch, on YouTube, a moving video of reporter Lilia Luciano’s visit to Liam’s classroom, where she recorded his fellow students telling him how much they loved and missed him, waving and blowing him kisses. His teachers decided not to remove Liam’s things from his cubby because they had faith that he would return. Two Democratic US representatives from Texas, Joaquin Castro and Jasmine Crockett, visited the Dilley facility and were profoundly concerned about the condition of Liam and the other kids imprisoned there. Hundreds demonstrated at the facility during the representatives’ visit, and one could hear the children begging to be freed. Partly because of the congressional representatives’ intercession and the public attention that Liam’s suffering attracted, his case came before federal judge Fred Biery, who ruled that the detention of Liam and his father was unconstitutional – and both father and son have now been released. In his statement, Biery stated that the case “has its genesis in the ill-conceived and incompetently implemented of daily deportation quotas, apparently even if it requires traumatizing children … For some among us, the perfidious lust for unbridled power and the imposition of cruelty in its quest know no bounds and are bereft of human decency.” He accused our government of ignoring the Declaration of Independence and “that pesky inconvenience called the Fourth Amendment”, which protects individuals from “unreasonable searches and seizures” without probable cause. The judge concluded his ruling with the now familiar photo of Liam and with a quote from the New Testament: “Jesus wept.” Of all the acts of brutality and senseless violence committed by the Department of Homeland Security and ICE during the past year, the arrest and incarceration of Liam Ramos and the other children who still remain in custody is among the most sickening and heartbreaking. Do the people abusing and imprisoning these kids have no children of their own? Do they have no “human decency”, no compassion? Have they forgotten that they were once children themselves? One conclusion reached about the rituals of slaughter at Auschwitz, Treblinka and other concentration and death camps – stripping the prisoners naked, making them run to the gas chambers – is that they were designed not to make the victims suffer but rather to dehumanize them in the eyes of the guards, who would then find it easier to murder their less-than-human captives. Is something similar occurring in our country? Did the agents who seized Liam Ramos not see that he is a human being, a child like their own kids, their family members, their former selves? Liam Ramos’s arrest – and the continuing incarceration of children in his situation – should be as much of a rallying point as the deaths of Renee Good and Alex Pretti. The Democrats who called for Liam’s freedom should demand the release of the other children in DHS internment facilities. Ideally, Liam – unlike Good and Pretti and the others murdered by ICE – will recover from the trauma inflicted on him through no fault of his own. Our nation can never sufficiently apologize or make up for what was done to Liam Ramos. But there a few potential outcomes that I would like to see in the aftermath of his ordeal. The first is that his story inspires a massive rethinking and overhaul of the way in which we the treat people who have come to this country to escape persecution and to live a more peaceful life. The second is that every US government official advocate for the children left behind at Dilley and similar detention centers. And my third hope is that Stephen Miller, the principal architect of our sadistic, racist, monstrous immigration policy, be kept awake, night after night, by the sweet face of Liam Ramos, floating above him in the darkness, so that Miller suffers the fate to which Shakespeare doomed Macbeth: sleep no more. Francine Prose is a former president of the PEN American Center and a member of the American Academy of Arts and Letters and the American Academy of Arts and Sciences This article was amended on 2 February 2026. A previous version misspelled a name in the headline.