May 18, 2026
The Iran war reminds us: we’ll never be energy-independent with fossil fuels | Lloyd Doggett and Michael Shank
Talking Points: The Iran War and Energy Independence
-
Protagonists and Context: In their compelling argument, U.S. Representative Lloyd Doggett and Dr. Michael Shank highlight how Donald Trump’s war on Iran and the ensuing global fuel crisis underscore the persistent vulnerability of nations reliant on fossil fuels.
-
Core Argument: They contend that true energy security and independence are unattainable as long as countries depend on finite fossil fuels, which are susceptible to geopolitical conflicts and attacks on energy infrastructure.
-
Implications for Policy: The authors advocate for a swift transition to decentralized, renewable energy sources, emphasizing that such a shift not only enhances energy security but also mitigates the risks associated with fossil fuel dependency, particularly in conflict-prone regions like Ukraine.
-
Call to Action: Doggett and Shank urge policymakers to support local renewable initiatives and decarbonization efforts, positing that embracing clean energy technologies is essential for achieving genuine freedom and security, both domestically and globally.

Stoic Response
Stoic Field Manual Entry: Energy Independence and the Iran War
What is Within Our Power
- Personal Agency: We can choose our responses to geopolitical conflicts and energy crises.
- Advocacy for Change: Supporting local renewable energy initiatives and policies that promote decentralized energy sources is within our control.
- Education and Awareness: We can educate ourselves and others about the benefits of renewable energy and the risks of fossil fuel dependency.
What is Opinion
- Perception of Security: The belief that fossil fuel reliance equates to energy security is a flawed perspective.
- Political Narratives: Opinions surrounding the motivations and actions of political figures, such as Trump’s energy policies, are subjective and open to interpretation.
- Transition Feasibility: There are varying opinions on the speed and effectiveness of transitioning to renewable energy sources.
What Action Virtue Demands
- Support Decarbonization: Actively advocate for and support policies that promote renewable energy and reduce reliance on fossil fuels.
- Community Engagement: Participate in local initiatives that aim to enhance energy independence and security through renewable sources.
- Resilience Building: Encourage and support efforts that help vulnerable communities, especially in conflict-prone regions, to transition to decentralized energy systems.
Conclusion
In the face of ongoing geopolitical tensions and the vulnerabilities created by fossil fuel dependency, it is our responsibility to take action. By focusing on what is within our power, understanding the nature of our opinions, and committing to virtuous actions, we can contribute to a future that prioritizes true energy independence and security for all.
Article Rewritten Through Stoic Lens
The Wisdom of Energy Independence: A Stoic Perspective
Understanding Our Sphere of Control
Dear students, let us reflect on the current events surrounding the conflict in Iran and the global energy crisis. In this tumultuous world, we must remember the Stoic principle of the dichotomy of control: we cannot control external events, but we can control our responses to them.
The Nature of Vulnerability
U.S. Representative Lloyd Doggett and Dr. Michael Shank remind us that our reliance on fossil fuels makes us vulnerable. Wars and geopolitical conflicts are beyond our control, yet how we choose to respond to this vulnerability is within our grasp. Let us practice discipline by recognizing that our security does not lie in finite resources but in our ability to adapt and innovate.
The Call for Energy Security
The authors argue that true energy independence is unattainable while we cling to these limited resources. Here lies an opportunity for judgment: we must discern the path towards sustainable energy. By embracing renewable sources, we can mitigate the risks associated with our current dependencies. This shift is not merely a policy change; it is a moral imperative for our time.
Embracing Decentralization
As we witness the impacts of conflict on energy infrastructure, we are reminded of the importance of decentralized energy systems. This is an opportunity to practice right action. By supporting local renewable initiatives, we not only enhance our energy security but also empower communities to take control of their destinies. This is the essence of Stoic resilience—transforming adversity into strength.
A Collective Responsibility
Doggett and Shank urge policymakers to act swiftly. Here, we must reflect on our role as citizens. Each of us has the power to influence change. By advocating for clean energy technologies, we contribute to a future that embodies true freedom and security. The Stoic sage understands that while we cannot control the actions of others, we can control our own advocacy and choices.
Lessons from Ukraine
Consider the response of Ukrainian communities to the ongoing conflict. They are transitioning to renewable energy sources, demonstrating resilience in the face of adversity. This is a powerful teaching moment: when faced with challenges, we can choose to adapt and innovate. Let us learn from their example, recognizing that our actions can lead to greater security and independence.
The Path Forward
As we engage with these pressing issues, let us remember that the transition to renewable energy is not just a technical challenge but a philosophical one. It requires us to align our actions with our values. By moving away from fossil fuels, we embrace a future that is not only sustainable but also just.
Conclusion: A Stoic Vision for the Future
In conclusion, the events surrounding the Iran war and energy independence present us with profound opportunities for growth. We must cultivate discipline, exercise sound judgment, and commit to right action. The path to true freedom lies in our ability to harness the infinite resources of the earth and empower our communities. Let us strive to embody these Stoic principles as we navigate the complexities of our world.
Source Body Text
Donald Trump’s unjustified war on Iran and the resulting global fuel crisis is a continuing reminder that true energy security and independence will continue to elude us so long as we remain dependent on fossil fuels. Whether it’s wars over oil and gas resource access or attacks on fossil fuel power plants and energy grids, this reliance on finite resources only worsens a country’s threat profile. News this month of Russia’s deadly attacks on Ukraine’s energy infrastructure, Russian drones swarming Ukrainian power stations, and Kyiv running out of time to prepare for another winter of attacks on its energy grid illustrates this urgency. No country will be energy-secure or independent as long as its fuel supply remains finite and fossilized and its power plants and energy grids centralized and fossil fuel-dependent. Those are sitting ducks, targets very vulnerable to attack by adversaries. There is another way to bolster energy security and independence: decarbonized and decentralized energy. Using local, renewable resources to power, heat and cool a community, with battery storage for backup, provides immediate relief from being precariously power plant-dependent or grid-dependent. That’s what Ukrainian communities are increasingly doing in response to Russian attacks on their fossil-fueled power plants and energy grids. In direct response to Russia’s war, municipalities all across Ukraine are making the switch fast. With the Iran war accelerating the transition to renewable energy, the gains from energy transition are obvious: countries like Spain are rapidly transitioning to renewables – better insulating themselves from gas price shocks and better protecting themselves from future grid-wide blackouts. In this global rush to get off fossil fuels, however, we can’t leave those on the frontlines behind. With no end in sight for Russian aggression, more Ukrainian power plants and energy grids will be bombed, leaving more without power, heat and water. Many Ukrainians who were fortunate enough to have heat this past winter had already made the switch to solar power, heat pumps and battery storage backup, thanks to the help of local non-profit organizations like EcoAction and Ecoclub, and donors abroad. Efforts like the Hromada Project, which is named after the Ukrainian term for “community”, will be essential in helping Ukrainians weather the war by connecting local nongovernmental organizations in Ukraine to public- and private-sector support from around the world. That’s exactly what our government should be doing: helping communities around the world be more energy secure and independent, sourcing their power locally with renewables, storing energy in batteries for backup, and electrifying everything to make the transition seamless. That’s certainly what is happening in China, which has dominated the global wind, solar, battery and electric vehicle markets as a result. Instead, Trump and his Republican followers seek to keep the US addicted to fossilized thinking. Weaponizing the Department of Defense to stall onshore wind development, repealing tax incentives for renewable energy development and using taxpayer dollars to bribe clean energy developers to abandon projects endangers our ability to adopt secure, affordable and clean energy technologies now. Forcing Americans to remain dependent on ageing fossil fuel infrastructure exposes us to increasing residential electricity rates and riskier grid conditions. Before another war is waged, and American defense budgets doubled, now is the time to double down on what will make us truly secure and independent. Transitioning off the fuels that start wars, and transitioning on to the energies that are decentralized, infinite and available in every community and country on this planet: that’s what real freedom looks like – and it’s all within our grasp. The US representative Lloyd Doggett serves Texas’s 37th district in the House of Representatives and is a member of the Ukraine caucus and the House sustainable energy and environment coalition. Michael Shank PhD is adjunct faculty at New York University’s Center for Global Affairs, and at George Mason University’s Carter School for Peace and Conflict Resolution