A Stoic SaysA Stoic Says logo - Daily Stoic philosophy and wisdom

June 12, 2026

Welcome to ‘the Claw’: the White House fighting cage captures Trump era rot | Sidney Blumenthal

In his article, Sidney Blumenthal critiques Donald Trump's plans to demolish the East Wing of the White House for a massive ballroom, highlighting the legal and ethical implications of such unilateral actions. Judge Patricia Millet's questioning during a court hearing reveals concerns about the potential for unchecked presidential power, as Trump's administration argues for absolute immunity in decision-making. The centerpiece of this spectacle is "the Claw," a large structure hosting a UFC event to celebrate Trump's 80th birthday, which Blumenthal argues serves as a corrupt vehicle for political and financial gain. Ultimately, the author concludes that this event symbolizes the moral decay and authoritarian tendencies of the Trump era, contrasting it starkly with the ideals represented by the Statue of Liberty.

Thumbnail for Welcome to ‘the Claw’: the White House fighting cage captures Trump era rot | Sidney Blumenthal

Stoic Response

Ethics & DutyPolitics & GovernanceJustice & Rights

Address to Students in the Stoa

Greetings, students. Today we gather to reflect upon the tumult of our times, particularly the spectacle surrounding the actions of those in power. Let us examine the judgments we form and the desires we harbor, for therein lies the path to wisdom.

The Issue at Hand

We find ourselves amidst a political theater where decisions are made unilaterally, often disregarding the very principles of justice and accountability. The demolition of the East Wing of the White House for a grand ballroom, amidst the shadows of the Statue of Liberty, raises profound questions about authority and morality.

Challenge Unhealthy Judgments

  • Question the Narrative: Are we merely spectators, or do we allow ourselves to be swayed by the rhetoric of power?
  • Seek Clarity: Distinguish between the appearance of legality and the essence of justice.
  • Discern the True Motives: What lies beneath the surface of grand celebrations? Is it genuine or a facade for corruption?

Anchor in Discipline

To navigate these turbulent waters, we must cultivate a disciplined approach to our desires, impulses, and assent:

  1. Desire:

    • Cultivate Resilience: Desire for power and influence can lead to moral decay. Seek instead the desire for virtue and integrity.
    • Practice Moderation: Recognize the allure of excess and strive for balance in all things.
  2. Impulse:

    • Pause Before Action: In moments of urgency, take a breath. Reflect on the implications of your choices.
    • Align Actions with Values: Ensure that your impulses are guided by reason and ethical considerations, not mere reaction.
  3. Assent:

    • Question Your Agreements: Just because a notion is popular does not make it right. Challenge the status quo when it conflicts with your principles.
    • Commit to Truth: Assent only to ideas that align with justice and the greater good, not those that serve self-interest.

Imperatives for Action

  • Engage with Intention: Participate in the discourse of our time, but do so with a clear mind and a virtuous heart.
  • Demand Accountability: Hold those in power to the standards of justice. Let not their actions go unchecked.
  • Embrace Your Role: As citizens, we are stewards of the ideals that underpin our society. Uphold them with courage.

In closing, remember that the true measure of our character is not found in the tumult of politics but in the quiet resolve of our actions. Let us strive for a world where liberty and justice prevail over the clamor of self-interest.

Act with Wisdom

Let us rise above the chaos and embody the principles we hold dear. The future depends on our discipline, our judgments, and our unwavering commitment to a just society.

Article Rewritten Through Stoic Lens

The Stoic Perspective on Power and Responsibility

Understanding Control: The Dichotomy of Power

In contemplating the actions of those in power, we must first recognize the dichotomy of control. As Judge Patricia Millet questioned the very foundations of presidential authority, we are reminded that while we cannot control the decisions of others, we can control our responses to them. The essence of Stoicism lies in discerning what is within our power and what is not.

The Unchecked Power of the Presidency

When faced with the prospect of demolishing the East Wing of the White House, we see a manifestation of unchecked authority. The administration's claim to absolute immunity serves as a reminder that while we cannot dictate the actions of those in power, we can choose to engage in reasoned judgment. Reflect on your own life: how often do we allow external circumstances to dictate our inner peace? True strength lies in maintaining our integrity regardless of the chaos around us.

The Spectacle of "The Claw"

The rise of "the Claw," a structure designed for entertainment, symbolizes a deeper moral decay. It is easy to be swept away by the allure of spectacle, but we must ask ourselves: What values do we uphold? This is an opportunity to practice discipline. Instead of succumbing to the distractions of the world, we can focus on our own character and the principles we wish to embody.

The Illusion of Freedom

As the UFC event is marketed as a celebration of freedom, we must scrutinize the true nature of such claims. Are we truly free if our actions are dictated by external forces? The Stoic sage understands that freedom is an internal state, achieved through virtue and wisdom. Let us not be deceived by the superficiality of events that seek to bind us to the whims of those in power.

The Contrast with Liberty

In juxtaposing "the Claw" with the Statue of Liberty, we see a stark contrast between authentic ideals and hollow displays. Liberty represents the promise of equality and hope, while the spectacle embodies a self-serving agenda. This serves as a reminder to cultivate our own values, choosing to embody the principles of justice and compassion in our daily lives.

The Role of Judgment in Action

The lawsuit against the administration highlights the importance of judgment and accountability. While we may not have the power to influence every decision made by our leaders, we can exercise our judgment in our own lives. How do we respond to injustice? Do we remain passive, or do we act in accordance with our values? Each moment presents an opportunity to practice right action.

The Influence of Wealth and Power

As we observe the intertwining of wealth and political influence, we are reminded of the transience of material gain. The pursuit of power for its own sake leads to moral decay. In our own lives, we must strive to seek virtue over wealth, recognizing that true fulfillment comes from living in accordance with our principles, not from the accumulation of riches.

Embracing Our Responsibility

In a world where the actions of others may seem overwhelming, we must embrace our responsibility to ourselves and our communities. The Stoic path encourages us to focus on what we can control: our thoughts, our actions, and our responses. Let us not be mere spectators in this grand spectacle but active participants in shaping a just and virtuous world.

Conclusion: The Path of the Stoic

As we reflect on the events surrounding the Trump administration, let us remember that the Stoic journey is one of self-mastery and discernment. We cannot control the actions of others, but we can control our own responses. In every challenge lies an opportunity to practice discipline, judgment, and right action. Embrace these teachings, and let them guide you toward a life of virtue amidst the chaos.

Source Body Text

“If the government decides, very quickly, to bulldoze the Statue of Liberty – the people whose ancestors that was the first thing they saw coming to this country, but the government moved too fast – nothing can be done?” asked Judge Patricia Millet of the District of Columbia court of appeals on 5 June to the principal deputy assistant attorney general, Yaakov Roth. “I think that’s right, yes,” he replied. In the case brought by the National Trust for Historic Preservation against Donald Trump’s “sudden, unilateral, and unlawful decision” to demolish the East Wing of the White House and to construct a 90,000 sq ft ballroom, “without seeking approval from Congress; without requesting review and approval from the federal commissions charged with oversight of development in the nation’s capital; without conducting the required environmental studies; and without allowing the public any opportunity for input”, Trump’s Department of Justice has countered that he can simply do whatever he wishes, whenever he wishes, however he wishes. “When did it become a fait accompli?” Judge Millett asked. “If this were complete lawlessness by the government … it couldn’t be stopped?” “On these theories, I think that’s right,” said Roth. “If you move fast enough, nobody has standing to challenge it?” asked Millet. “I do think that that is correct,” Roth said. “The injury, it becomes non-redressable.” The supreme court’s 2024 campaign ruling granting “absolute” presidential immunity for “official acts” is Trump’s Magna Carta for absolute rule. But if the president can do anything, anytime, anywhere, why even bother now with the irrelevance of the judicial system except as a residual bow to empty formal courtesy? Why dress up the “non-redressable”? At the same time that the justice department insisted that Trump could demolish the Statue of Liberty at will, a monstrous and gaudy 600-tonne, 154ft-tall skeletal structure called “the Claw”, painted red, white and blue, was rising on the South Lawn of the White House, above the building itself and next to the rubble where the ballroom is planned. Within “the Claw” there will be a cage, where the Ultimate Fighting Championship company will stage martial arts matches, an exhibition called “UFC Freedom 250”, to celebrate Trump’s 80th birthday on 14 June. The cage fighter weigh-ins and face-offs will take place at the Lincoln Memorial, where the solemn marble Daniel Chester French statue is flanked by the engraved words of the Gettysburg Address (“a new birth of freedom”) and the Second Inaugural (“malice toward none”). On the Ellipse, in the shadow of the Washington Monument, jumbotron TV screens will show the fight to tens of thousands of fans who have not been invited to join the select few designated by Trump to sit ringside with him at “the Claw”. The event is billed as “free”, but in reality it appears to be an occasion for many complex transactions for Trump to further his economic and political control, reward members of his inner network and deepen his influence over them. While the fighters are the ostensible draw, they are not the true main event. They are a pretext for Trump’s kleptocratic spectacle. The gladiatorial grappling has given Trump a chance to extract tribute for his favor, to put the federal government out to the highest bidder, to bind his big money allies closer to him, to make them more dependent. Not least, on his birthday, the circus revolves around him as the center of attention. “This plan is deeply corrupt,” states the lawsuit brought by the non-profit Public Integrity Project in an effort to stop the “unlawful” event from taking place. “UFC Freedom 250 is a private, for-profit sporting event being ‘planned, organized, and executed’ by the UFC, its broadcast partners, and its advertisers, not by the federal government. And it is not in any material sense a ‘celebration of the 250th anniversary of American Independence’ – it is, instead, a celebration of the UFC’s brand and the 80th anniversary of Donald Trump’s birth. “For these reasons, UFC Freedom 250 does not satisfy the strict conditions that must be satisfied for special semiquincentennial events to occur on the South Lawn or at the Lincoln Memorial.” The UFC is offering special access VIP packages, “Partnership Investment”, for $1.5m. Two weeks after the match was announced, Trump’s “wealth advisers” purchased up to $50,000 of stock in TKO Holding Group, the UFC’s parent company. One TKO executive touted the upcoming event as “the greatest earned-marketing tool of all time”. Marketing is everything to the UFC. Dana White, impresario of the UFC, owes Donald Trump for his first promotional break. The UFC was essentially a shell company in 2001 when White became its president after arranging its sale to a group of casino investors. Senator John McCain called it “human cockfighting”. The company’s activity was prohibited in 36 states and on pay-per-view cable TV. At that moment, Trump himself was also floundering. His Atlantic City hotel and casino, the Taj Mahal, had already been subjected to a bankruptcy. He hired the UFC for its first public matches to attract a crowd, which did not prevent the Taj eventually from collapsing into its final bankruptcy. But Trump gave the UFC visibility. White also hired a knock-about comedian and actor, Joe Rogan, as a color commentator. Then 15 years later, in 2016, White sold the UFC to WME, the entertainment agency, for $4bn. White has been elevated into a cultural icon of the Trump age. He spoke on the podium of the 2024 Republican convention for Trump, contributes mightily to Trump’s political action committee and hosts Trump at UFC events where he enters like a conquering Caesar. The Public Integrity Project lawsuit notes that White “admitted that the event was ‘Trump’s idea’”. Trump is staging a version of his past, when he brought the fledgling and proscribed UFC to his dying casino, but is now re-enacting the tawdry scene as a grand success using all the resources at his command in a celebration of his web of influence and himself. Plebes may also pay a streaming service to see it, but not just any one. For an $8.99 plus tax subscription fee, viewers at home can see the event on Paramount+, owned by Larry Ellison and his son David Ellison, who are seeking Department of Justice approval of the takeover of Warner Brothers Discovery, and who put CBS News under the unerring mismanagement of Bari Weiss. The cage match is expected to leverage millions of subscription sign-ups, sell expensive commercials to corporate sponsors that want to curry Trump’s favor, and establish Paramount+ as a live sports competitor with Netflix and Amazon Prime. In fact, Paramount+ has emerged as the home for all UFC events under a seven-year contract with the TKO Group. The deal has a projected annual value of $1.1bn. That agreement came almost immediately after the Trump justice department granted approval for the Ellison-owned Skydance company to purchase Paramount for $8bn. In what appears to be an attempt to clear the way for the Federal Communication Commission’s blessing, Paramount paid a $16m personal settlement to Trump to resolve his lawsuit in which he accused CBS News’s 60 Minutes of deceptively editing an interview with Kamala Harris. David Ellison declared that “the addition of UFC’s year-round must-watch events to our platforms is a major win”. A Republican lobbyist told NBC News about the Trump political operation’s frenetic activity surrounding the UFC event: “They are raising a shit-ton of money and have used it as another unofficial vehicle for corporate donors to give and gain favor with Trump.” The night before the match, Trump is holding a $1m-a-person dinner at the Trump National Golf Club at Potomac, Virginia, for Super Pac Maga Inc. Since the 2024 election, Maga Inc has raised more than $342m from “the GOP’s legacy donor class and its newer crop of tech and finance billionaires,” any number of them recipients of federal contracts or reliant on federal regulation, according to Forbes Magazine. The corporate operator of Crypto.com, for example, has donated $20m, and as part of Crypto.com’s deal with the UFC, giving Crypto branding rights on all fighters’ uniforms, it is offering “a first of its kind, $1 million $CRO bonus pool for the Fight of the Night”. “Maybe we’ll never, ever take it down,” Trump mused in a videoon his TikTok account about “the Claw”. He compared it to the Eiffel Tower, built as a temporary structure for the 1889 Paris World’s Fair. And “maybe”, following the doctrine promulgated by his justice department, he will keep “the Claw” and “bulldoze” the Statue of Liberty, “maybe” just to prove the point that he can. The two structures are opposing symbols of the Trump era. The Statue of Liberty was built as the project of French liberals as a gift of the people of France to commemorate the Union victory in the civil war. In Liberty’s left hand, she holds a tablet on which is written “JULY IV MDCCLXXVI”– 4 July 1776 – and at her feet lie broken shackles representing emancipation from slavery, redemption of the revolutionary promise in the Declaration of Independence that “all men are created equal.” Liberty faces Europe holding in her right hand an upraised beacon to shine for liberalism and freedom, in Lincoln’s words, the United States as “the last best hope of earth”. The funds for the statue were provided by the American public in a subscription drive launched by Joseph Pulitzer’s New York World. For that drive, the poet Emma Lazarus wrote The New Colossus, whose lines expressing the American promise to immigrants are inscribed at the statue: “Give me your tired, your poor / Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free.” “The Claw” overarching the cage for brutal combat is the physical representation of Trump’s Hobbesian vision for the rest of us while he presides in the owner’s box. That cage also signifies the many cages Trump has built for immigrants, a kind of sculptural Salvadorian Cecot of his own on the South Lawn. But, more, Trump’s cage, his regime, has been lowered on the whole country to entrap it. Bombs away again, but then not for now. “I love inflation.” After Trump attended the third game of the NBA Finals at Madison Square Garden on 9 June, where he was heartily booed during the national anthem by the New York fans who are all too familiar with him and might not take well to the bulldozing of the Statue of Liberty, Joe Rogan, the original color commentator, sagely remarked: “He should stick to the UFC, they’re going to boo him everywhere else.” Sidney Blumenthal, former senior adviser to President Bill Clinton and Hillary Clinton, has published three books of a projected five-volume political life of Abraham Lincoln: A Self-Made Man, Wrestling With His Angel and All the Powers of Earth. He is a Guardian US columnist