A Stoic SaysA Stoic Says logo - Daily Stoic philosophy and wisdom

August 30, 2026

Italy may ban staring at your phone while crossing the street. Why stop there? | Dave Schilling

In his article, Dave Schilling discusses Italy's proposal to ban phone use while crossing streets, suggesting fines of €75 for distracted pedestrians. He highlights the dangers of this behavior, not only in Italy but globally, emphasizing the need for increased awareness of traffic safety. Schilling applauds the Italian government's initiative and humorously proposes additional fines for various social annoyances, advocating for a more considerate public environment. Ultimately, he argues that addressing these small irritations could significantly improve daily life.

Thumbnail for Italy may ban staring at your phone while crossing the street. Why stop there? | Dave Schilling

Stoic Response

Ethics & DutyCulture & IdentityPolitics & Governance

Correspondence to a Roman Magistrate

From the Wisdom of Seneca and Musonius Rufus

Honorable Magistrate,

In the spirit of our esteemed forebears, I pen this correspondence to address a matter of increasing import in our bustling streets. As Seneca wisely stated, “We suffer more often in imagination than in reality.” This rings true in our present age, where the distractions of modernity pull our attention away from the immediate dangers that surround us.

Statistic of Concern

Consider the alarming statistic that pedestrian fatalities have risen by over 30% in the past decade due to distractions, a trend mirrored not only in Italy but across the globe. This underscores the urgent need for intervention. The proposal to impose fines for distracted pedestrians, as advocated by the Italian government, serves as a necessary signal to our citizens: vigilance in our daily lives is paramount.

Moral Stakes

Yet, the stakes extend beyond mere statistics. The very fabric of our communal existence is threatened when individuals prioritize their devices over their surroundings. We become, as Musonius Rufus would argue, responsible not just for our own safety, but for the well-being of our fellow citizens. A moment's distraction can lead to irreversible consequences, transforming a simple act of crossing a street into a tragic event.

Practical Maxims

Thus, let us adopt the following maxims to guide our conduct:

  1. Attend to Your Surroundings: In every endeavor, be it walking or conversing, let your attention be fully present.
  2. Consider the Collective: Your actions impact not only yourself but the community. Act with the awareness that you share this space with others.
  3. Embrace Simplicity: In a world rife with distractions, choose simplicity over complexity. Silence your devices when in public spaces.
  4. Promote Awareness: Advocate for the well-being of others by encouraging mindful behavior in shared environments.

May these principles guide our actions and foster a safer, more considerate society.

With respect and wisdom,
[Your Name]
A humble servant of the Republic

Article Rewritten Through Stoic Lens

The Stoic Path to Awareness: Lessons from Italy's Proposed Ban on Distracted Walking

The Dichotomy of Control: Understanding Our Actions

Imagine, dear students, navigating the narrow streets of Italy, where the ancient cobblestones meet the modern chaos of our world. In such a setting, we are reminded of the dichotomy of control: while we cannot control the actions of others, we can govern our own responses. The Italian government’s proposal to fine distracted pedestrians serves as a poignant reminder of the importance of awareness and discipline in our daily lives.

External Events as Teaching Moments

Consider the act of walking while engrossed in our devices. This behavior, while seemingly trivial, poses significant dangers. It is a call to practice judgment: we must discern what is within our control—our focus and attention. The proposed fine of €75 for distracted walking is not merely punitive; it is an invitation to cultivate mindfulness. Reflect on how often we allow distractions to steer us away from the present moment.

The Importance of Paying Attention

When we find ourselves in situations where others are oblivious to their surroundings, we must remember that our response is what matters. Instead of frustration, let us embrace right action. The Stoic sage understands that while we cannot control the behavior of those around us, we can choose to remain vigilant and composed. In doing so, we protect not only ourselves but also those who may be unaware of the impending dangers.

Transforming Annoyances into Opportunities for Growth

Schilling humorously suggests additional fines for social irritations, such as loud ringtones or interruptions. Here, we see another opportunity to practice Stoic principles. Each annoyance is a chance to cultivate patience and tolerance. Rather than allowing irritation to cloud our judgment, we can choose to respond with understanding. The Stoic recognizes that external disturbances do not dictate our inner peace.

Small Actions, Significant Impact

Consider the seemingly minor act of pushing in a chair at a restaurant. This simple gesture can prevent accidents and demonstrate respect for others. It is a reminder that our actions, no matter how small, contribute to the greater good. By practicing such mindfulness, we embody the Stoic ideal of living in harmony with our community.

Navigating the World with Purpose

As we reflect on the dangers of riding scooters on sidewalks, let us remember that our choices shape our reality. The Stoic understands that while we cannot control the actions of others, we can influence our environment through our own decisions. Choose to walk mindfully, to respect the rules of the road, and to advocate for safety—not only for ourselves but for those around us.

Conclusion: A Call to Stoic Discipline

In conclusion, the Italian government's initiative serves as a profound reminder of the Stoic principles we must embody in our daily lives. Each external event is an opportunity for growth, each annoyance a chance to practice discipline and judgment. Let us embrace these lessons, cultivating a life of awareness, respect, and right action. In doing so, we not only improve our own lives but also contribute to a more considerate world.

Source Body Text

Imagine driving in Italy, with its narrow, cobblestone streets and scooter enthusiasts. I find it hard enough to drive in Los Angeles, a city designed specifically with the automobile in mind. I’d probably squash a pedestrian or two trying to navigate Italian roads. The modern world is just too hectic for the ancient streets of Europe, so Italy is considering doing the only sensible thing it can: outlawing texting in crosswalks. The Italian government’s updated draft of its highway code proposes fines of €75 or more for anyone caught sending a DM, updating their LinkedIn, finishing Wordle on the fifth guess, or anything else phone-related that might make them miss an oncoming metal projectile. I’m sure most people will risk the slap on wrist to get that message off, but it at least sends a signal to the Italian people that paying attention to traffic is actually kind of important. Distracted pedestrians aren’t just a problem in Italy, though. If I’m turning right on a red light, chances are there will be someone inching slowly toward the intersection with their thumbs furiously smashing against the glass of their iPhone, oblivious to the fact that I am planning to drive into the parcel of land they are currently occupying. It’s not just that this behavior is dangerous. It’s also deeply annoying. I’m forced to pay attention for both of us, like I’m a guardian angel or the arbiter of whether you, the clueless phone person, live or die. Sure, I might briefly get off on the power trip of having such authority over our mutual safety, but I’d much rather be thinking about where to have dinner instead of how long I should wait to honk at the drooling simpleton preventing me from turning. I applaud the Italian government for their forward thinking. Actually, I think it’s time we criminalize more small annoyances. Such as … Using a ringtone Someone please explain to me why anyone bothers with leaving their ringer on. We are decades past the era when, for a dollar, you could buy that Crazy Frog song and impress your friends every time you got a call. Now, it’s just pure sonic detritus, clogging up our ears with aural poison – bleeps, bloops, pings and plops. When AMC Theaters tells an auditorium full of grown adults to silence their phones before a movie, all I can think is: “Unless they’re an on-call heart surgeon, their phone should always be silent.” Fine amount: $200 Interrupting me when I’m not done talking I understand and accept that I have a lot to say. I make my meager living from writing, so pontificating just comes naturally to me. Sometimes, I wish it didn’t. But most of the time, what I’m saying is pretty important and you should be listening. Not waiting for your turn. I just listened to you try to captivate me with a treatise on gender roles in Christopher Nolan’s films. I respected you, even if I didn’t want to. Either let me finish or you’re fined! Fine amount: $200 Not pushing in your chair when stepping away from a table at a restaurant Would you like to see the server at your favorite Olive Garden location break their tibia because you left your chair in the middle of a walkway? If that’s what you think of our restaurant industry workers, I’ve got a mind to go outside to my patio and bang on some pots and pans like it’s Covid lockdown to thank everyone carrying a plate of shrimp scampi who has to avoid rude customers. When you get up from your table, push in your chair. It takes two seconds and it could save a life … and a plate of delicious pasta. Fine amount: $250 Riding an electric scooter on the sidewalk I would like to remind everyone that scooters from companies such as Lime and Lyft explicitly say to not ride these vehicles on the sidewalk. The sidewalk is called a sidewalk because it, much like Nancy Sinatra’s boots, was made for walking. A motorized conveyance doesn’t belong on the sidewalk, especially ones that actually can get some real speed behind them. Use the bike lane, for God’s sake. Or take the bus. Or anything else, really. It’s just beyond dangerous to be tooling around on a scooter while people are trying to go about their business. I mean, what if I’m looking at my phone and texting? Shame on you, scooter guy. Fine amount: $500 Dave Schilling is a Los Angeles-based writer and humorist