A Stoic SaysA Stoic Says logo - Daily Stoic philosophy and wisdom

November 7, 2026

Will Pete Hegseth be the blue tsunami’s next victim? | Arwa Mahdawi

Executive Summary

The political landscape is shifting as Pete Hegseth, the U.S. Secretary of Defense, faces mounting scrutiny following the Republicans' disappointing midterm results. Key figures within his party, including outgoing senators and congressmen, are calling for his resignation and have threatened impeachment due to his controversial role in the U.S.-Israeli war on Iran. Despite Hegseth's public defiance and support from former President Trump, internal party dissent raises questions about his future. As the blame game intensifies, Hegseth's position appears increasingly precarious, suggesting potential leadership changes ahead.

Thumbnail for Will Pete Hegseth be the blue tsunami’s next victim? | Arwa Mahdawi

Stoic Response

Politics & GovernanceWar & ConflictJustice & Rights

Address to Students in the Stoa

Greetings, students. Today, we gather to reflect upon the tumultuous nature of our political landscape, particularly as we observe the unfolding events surrounding Secretary Hegseth. It is easy to become entangled in the web of judgments and emotions that such matters provoke. Yet, as Stoics, we must seek clarity and discipline in our responses.

Recognize the Challenge

  • Unhealthy Judgments: The fervor surrounding Hegseth’s predicament is rife with emotional judgments. We must ask ourselves: What is within our control?
  • Avoid Scapegoating: The blame cast upon individuals, while tempting, distracts us from our own responsibilities.

Anchor Your Thoughts

To navigate these turbulent waters, focus on three key disciplines:

  1. Desire:

    • Cultivate desires aligned with virtue.
    • Seek not the downfall of others but your own moral growth.
  2. Impulse:

    • Practice restraint in your reactions.
    • Reflect before acting; do not let anger dictate your response.
  3. Assent:

    • Question the narratives presented to you.
    • Challenge your initial judgments; are they rooted in truth or mere opinion?

Imperatives for a Stoic Life

  • Examine Your Desires:

    • What do you truly want? Is it fame, or is it wisdom? Choose wisely.
  • Control Your Impulses:

    • When faced with scandal, pause. Respond with reason, not rage.
  • Assess Your Assent:

    • Before embracing a judgment, ask: Is this thought beneficial? Seek clarity over convenience.

Conclusion

In the face of chaos, remember that the only true power lies within you. Strive to maintain your inner peace, regardless of external events. Let us not be swayed by the winds of public opinion but remain steadfast in our pursuit of virtue and wisdom.

Reflect and Act

  • Reflect: Consider how you can apply these principles in your daily life.
  • Act: Engage with the world, but do so with a Stoic heart—grounded, rational, and virtuous.

Let us walk this path together, embracing the discipline that leads to true freedom.

Article Rewritten Through Stoic Lens

Journal of Marcus Aurelius

On the Nature of Political Turmoil

Today, I reflect upon the shifting tides of political power, as one Pete Hegseth, a figure of considerable stature, finds himself ensnared in the web of scrutiny following the recent midterm elections. The tumult of the political arena serves as a reminder that all positions of authority are transient, subject to the whims of fortune and the collective judgment of the populace.

Acceptance of Nature’s Order

It is not uncommon for men in power to face challenges, and Hegseth is no exception. The call for his resignation echoes the ancient truth: that no man is invulnerable to the consequences of his actions. The dissatisfaction within his party, manifesting as calls for impeachment and resignation, is a natural response to perceived failures. I must remind myself that such discord is part of the greater order of life, where virtue and vice are continually weighed against one another.

The Path of Virtue Amidst Blame

As I observe the blame being cast upon Hegseth for the consequences of the U.S.-Israeli war on Iran, I am struck by the opportunity for virtue that arises from such adversity. In moments of crisis, one may choose to either succumb to despair or rise to the occasion, embodying the principles of wisdom, courage, and justice. It is in the crucible of public scrutiny that one’s character is truly revealed.

Contemplating the Role of Leadership

The defense secretary’s public defiance, despite mounting criticism, invites contemplation on the nature of true leadership. Is it not the mark of a wise leader to accept accountability rather than deflect blame? As I reflect on Hegseth’s position, I consider the importance of humility and the willingness to learn from one’s missteps. The wise man understands that his power is not a shield against criticism but a responsibility to serve the greater good.

The Illusion of Control

In the face of potential impeachment and internal dissent, I am reminded of the Stoic principle that we cannot control the actions of others, only our own responses. Hegseth’s insistence on remaining in his position, despite the storm surrounding him, reveals a desire for control that is ultimately an illusion. True strength lies in acceptance of fate and the understanding that all things must pass, including one’s tenure in power.

The Cycle of Justice

As I witness the unfolding events, I find solace in the belief that justice, though often delayed, is inevitable. The former admiral’s bid for Congress, fueled by Hegseth’s perceived incompetence, serves as a reminder that the scales of justice may tip in unexpected ways. It is a lesson that the universe has its own mechanisms for rectifying wrongs, and we must trust in its wisdom.

The Pursuit of the Good

In the midst of political strife, I reflect on the broader implications of our actions. The discontent among young men, as they turn away from established parties, speaks to a deeper yearning for authenticity and purpose. It is a call for leaders to embody the virtues of integrity and service, rather than mere ambition.

Final Reflections

As I conclude my reflections, I am reminded that the trials of one man are but a reflection of the greater human experience. Each challenge presents an opportunity for growth, both for the individual and for society. May we all strive to embrace our circumstances with grace, seeking to cultivate virtue even in the face of adversity. For it is in our responses to life’s challenges that we truly define ourselves.

Source Body Text

Can you smell the schadenfreude in the air? Watching some of the worst people in the world get their comeuppance this week has been deeply satisfying. And the show isn’t over yet. While the midterms have wrapped up, the blame game is only just getting started, with Republicans desperate to find scapegoats for their shellacking. He may be a big, strong, testosterone-obsessed warrior, but I suspect Pete Hegseth is panicking right now. When it comes to scapegoats, the defence secretary (or “war secretary” as he prefers to identify as) is an obvious choice. The disastrous US-Israeli war on Iran played a key role in the midterm upset, as even JD Vance has admitted, and Hegseth was one of its main architects. The Democrats have already declared war on the former Fox News personality. “In the majority, one of the first things we’re going to do is run Pete Hegseth out of town,” Hakeem Jeffries announced at a campaign rally before the midterms. It’s not just the Democrats; many of Hegseth’s peers are eager to give him the boot. The outgoing Republican senator Thom Tillis told CBS News on Tuesday night that Hegseth has a “reckoning” coming. Meanwhile, the (also outgoing) Republican congressman Thomas Massie told Bloomberg News he will “definitely” reintroduce articles of impeachment against Hegseth next week. (Massie has already tried to impeach Hegseth for starting the war in Iran without congressional approval.) In a Wednesday post on Twitter/X, Massie wrote: “There is one contingency in which I won’t reintroduce the articles of impeachment: Hegseth resigns.” There is little chance that Hegseth will unilaterally decide to make a dignified exit. On Thursday, the defense secretary posted a longwinded video in which, after rambling about DEI and trans people, he asserted that he wasn’t going anywhere. “A disgruntled, defeated congressman [aka Massie], along with all his Democrat allies, has also dropped sham articles of impeachment against yours truly, just like they tried against President Trump twice,” Hegseth said. “Didn’t work against President Trump, and it won’t work with me. You can rest assured of that.” This little performance did not quieten his critics. “@PeteHegseth, cabinet secretaries shouldn’t be wasting taxpayer dollars on campaign style videos,” Tillis wrote on social media in response. “This is about you: the incompetence you’ve displayed, the bad advice you’ve given to president, and your shameful and embarrassing episodes from firing our top generals to texting war plans to reporters.” There have been rather a lot of shameful and embarrassing episodes in Hegseth’s career, haven’t there? There are all the allegations about his previous drunk and disorderly conduct, for example. And the settlement he paid to a woman who accused him of raping her in 2017. And the time his own mother called him an “abuser of women”. (He’s denied any wrongdoing.) And the New Yorker’s report that, in 2015, Hegseth was accused of drunkenly chanting “Kill All Muslims! Kill All Muslims!” (Hegseth’s lawyer told the New Yorker that they weren’t going to comment on these “outlandish claims”.) And the time he accidentally sent top secret war plans in a Signal group chat that included a reporter from the Atlantic. And then, of course, there are all the alleged war crimes he’s responsible for. Hegseth loves to rail against “DEI hires”, but imagine for a moment if a woman was texting classified information to the wrong people and battling scandal after scandal. There’s no way she’d still be heading up the Pentagon. As has been widely observed, Trump seems to like getting rid of his high-level female officials when they embarrass him, while holding on to his mediocre men. Indeed, while the secretary of war may be on the defensive now, there’s always the depressing possibility that his sex – and his sycophancy towards the president – may end up saving him. Particularly as Trump is publicly standing by his man for the moment. When asked on Wednesday if he was considering replacing Hegseth, Trump told reporters: “No, I think ⁠he’s doing a very good job.” Behind the scenes, of course, it could be a different story. NBC News reported on Wednesday that Trump has told some of his allies that he’s considering replacing the defense secretary. But even if Hegseth is able to cling on to the sinking ship until it finally goes down, I take solace in the fact that he must be feeling very uncomfortable right now. And I am clinging on to hope that he will have a very public downfall. This is, let’s not forget, a man who wanted to livestream an execution via firing squad. While that thankfully never happened, perhaps we’ll all get to watch a live stream of Hegseth getting fired. Navy admiral fired by Hegseth flips South Carolina seat Nancy Lacore was in the navy for 35 years before the three-star admiral was ousted by Hegseth without cause amid a broader purge. In response, she mounted a bid for Congress that made Hegseth’s incompetence a key talking point. At the time of writing, the race hasn’t been officially called, but it looks like she’s managed to flip a traditionally Republican seat. Wouldn’t it be poetic if she plays a part in firing Pete? Young white men abandoned the Republicans at the midterms “Eighteen- to 29-year-old young white men with no college degrees swung 40 points to the Democrats, and I don’t think it’s all because they’re socialists,” the podcaster Tim Pool told Fox News. “I think it’s because many of them want to burn the Republican party down.” Go ahead, guys! Russell Brand found guilty of rape and sexual assault Part of Brand’s defence was the claim: “Not one of [the victims] resisted or screamed or even tried to leave.” Speaking after the trial, the victims’ commissioner for England and Wales, Claire Waxman, emphasized how dangerous these sorts of misconceptions about sexual assault are. “The idea that rape victims must scream, physically resist or immediately report an offence is a well-established rape myth, rooted in outdated and harmful assumptions about how victims are expected to behave,” she said. “Justice must be grounded in evidence, not misconceptions.” Amtrak wants to let passengers bring guns on trains Just when you think the US is getting a smidgen more sane, you see something like this. West Bank school on high alert after settler violence Israeli militants killed five teenage students at al-Mughayyir school in the West Bank last academic year, one at the school gates. In response to parents being afraid to send their kids back to the classroom, the school has had to build bigger fences. Meanwhile, “settlers” continue their violent pogroms on the village, and far too many US politicians continue to excuse and enable this violence. How ‘Crunchy Moms’ became ‘the most dangerous group on Facebook’ A Guardian investigation has found that groups such as Crunchy Moms (which has more than 490,000 members) are hives of anti-vaccine content and medical misinformation. Most alarmingly: Meta “appears to have helped spread such ideas by promoting Crunchy Moms into users’ feeds, even when they do not seek it out”. The week in pawtriarchy While the midterms were on everyone’s mind this week, an alligator in North Carolina was just thinking about brunch. Surveillance cameras caught the creature strolling into the back of a bagel shop, startling the customers. The police were called and the gator was removed. The gator insists he did nothing wrong and is the victim of a schmear campaign. Arwa Mahadwi is a Guardian columnist