November 10, 2026
ChatGPT’s Teen Mode could deprive teenagers of a fundamental need | Robin Kirman
In her thought-provoking piece, Robin Kirman critiques OpenAI's newly launched Teen Mode for ChatGPT, arguing that while it aims to protect teenagers from harmful content, it may inadvertently stifle their essential developmental journey. Kirman, a psychoanalyst, highlights that the mode's supportive features could create a dependency that undermines adolescents' ability to form their own identities and internal compass. She draws on psychological theories to emphasize that true growth comes from facing challenges independently, warning that this reliance on AI could deepen the youth mental health crisis. Ultimately, Kirman calls for a reevaluation of how technology interacts with the formative experiences of young people, suggesting that the most profound losses may be those we cannot easily measure.

Stoic Response
Stoic Meditation for Dawn Practice
Author's Claim
Robin Kirman argues that while OpenAI's Teen Mode for ChatGPT aims to protect teenagers from harmful content, it may inadvertently hinder their essential developmental journey. She posits that the supportive features of this mode could create a dependency that undermines adolescents' ability to form their identities and internal compass.
Weighing Against Nature and Logos
In nature, growth often comes from facing challenges and navigating discomfort. Kirman highlights that "true growth comes from facing challenges independently," suggesting that the essence of development lies in overcoming obstacles rather than avoiding them. This aligns with Stoic philosophy, which teaches that virtue and wisdom are cultivated through trials. The logos, or rational order of the universe, emphasizes that struggle is a natural part of life and essential for personal growth.
Actionable Reflections
-
Embrace Discomfort: As you begin your day, reflect on the challenges you face. Rather than seeking to avoid them, consider how they can contribute to your personal growth. Ask yourself: What discomforts can I lean into today?
-
Cultivate Independence: Evaluate your reliance on external sources for validation or support. Are there areas in your life where you can practice self-reliance? Challenge yourself to make decisions based on your own reasoning rather than seeking approval from others.
-
Foster Authenticity: Take a moment to journal about your beliefs and values. What do you truly think and feel? Strive to articulate your thoughts without the influence of external validation, recognizing that your internal compass is your most reliable guide.
-
Practice Mindfulness: Throughout your day, pause and reflect on your thoughts and feelings. Are they influenced by external pressures? Ground yourself in the present moment and remind yourself that true understanding comes from within.
-
Encourage Others: If you mentor or support young people, encourage them to confront their challenges independently. Share with them the value of struggle in forming a stable sense of self, and remind them that it is okay to feel discomfort in the process of growth.
Conclusion
As the sun rises, let this meditation remind you that true growth arises from the trials we face. Embrace the discomfort, cultivate your independence, and trust your internal compass. In doing so, you not only honor your own journey but also set an example for those around you.
Article Rewritten Through Stoic Lens
The Wisdom of Stoicism in the Age of Technology
Understanding Control: The Dichotomy of Control
In our exploration of the modern world, we must first grasp the fundamental Stoic principle: the dichotomy of control. Recognize what lies within your power and what does not. The advent of Teen Mode in technology, while seemingly protective, presents us with a profound opportunity to reflect on our own judgments and actions.
External Events: A Call to Discipline
OpenAI's introduction of Teen Mode is an external event, one that we cannot control. However, we can control our responses to it. This mode aims to shield the young from harmful content, yet it raises questions about the nature of growth. As Stoics, we must ask: does this protection foster true independence, or does it cultivate a dependency that stifles the development of character?
The Role of Adversity in Growth
Adversity is a teacher. Robin Kirman reminds us that true growth comes from facing challenges independently. The Stoic sage understands that it is through trials that we forge our identities. Thus, when confronted with the ease of AI assistance, we must choose to engage with our struggles. Embrace discomfort as a necessary component of personal development.
Judgment: The Power of Perception
As Kirman highlights, the reliance on AI can lead to a weakened internal compass. Herein lies our opportunity for judgment. We must discern between tools that aid us and those that hinder our self-discovery. The Stoic path encourages us to cultivate our own thoughts and beliefs rather than relying on external validation.
Right Action: The Path to Autonomy
Adolescence is a critical period for establishing one's identity. The wisdom of Donald Winnicott reminds us that a “good-enough” parent allows for struggle, fostering resilience. In the context of Teen Mode, we must ask ourselves: does this tool enable genuine learning, or does it remove the necessity of independent thought? The Stoic approach calls us to act rightly, embracing the discomfort of uncertainty as we navigate our own paths.
The Illusion of Security
While Teen Mode may offer a semblance of security, we must recognize that true stability comes from within. The Stoic understands that external circumstances are fleeting and often beyond our control. Instead, we must cultivate an internal sense of self that is resilient to the fluctuations of the world around us.
The Crucible of Self-Discovery
In moments of solitude and challenge, we encounter our true selves. The blank page, the unassisted task, becomes a crucible for self-discovery. As Schopenhauer noted, thinking for oneself is uncomfortable, yet it is essential for growth. We must resist the allure of constant assistance and embrace the struggle of independent thought.
Conclusion: Embracing the Stoic Path
In the face of technological advancements like Teen Mode, we are presented with a choice. We can either succumb to dependency or rise to the challenge of self-reliance. The Stoic path is one of discipline, judgment, and right action. Let us embrace the discomfort of uncertainty and cultivate our own minds, for it is through this journey that we truly come to know ourselves.
In every external event, let us find an opportunity to practice Stoic principles and strengthen our character.
Source Body Text
In August, OpenAI launched Teen Mode – a version of ChatGPT in which every user under 18 will automatically be enrolled – a year after a lawsuit alleged that ChatGPT had contributed to the suicide of a 16-year-old named Adam Raine. For years, the tech industry has contested any causal link between its products and the harms named in a wave of similar lawsuits, each alleging that the companies had not merely failed to protect children but had deliberately designed products to exploit them. Teen Mode is a tacit admission of culpability and it reveals what the industry now acknowledges – and doesn’t – about its products’ negative effects on young users’ mental health. As a psychoanalyst who works with young people, I’ve been observing, up close, the impact of social media and AI on their psychological development: how these tools influence not only behavior or mood at the day-to-day level, but identity formation and character. Teen mode may address some of the harms done to teenagers. A deeper one remains. At the surface level, Teen Mode seeks to prevent some of the more obvious harms to young users: it provides guardrails against destructive content, parent notifications for self-harm concerns, and a prohibition on presenting itself as a friend, claiming personal feelings, or suggesting it is anything other than a tool. That last restriction is a direct response to the Character.AI wrongful death case, in which a fourteen-year-old formed an intense attachment to a chatbot. There’s a growing awareness that it’s not only the content AI delivers but the way AI behaves that can cause harm, and that recognition seems to have driven the design of another feature: Study Mode, Teen Mode’s built-in learning tool. Recent research has confirmed what we already knew: that versions of AI that simply do the work for kids produce short-term grade improvements that collapse the moment the tool is removed, leaving students worse off than if they’d never used it. Study Mode is meant to yield gains that will hold. Leah Belsky, OpenAI’s vice-president for education, calls it a transformation from “a straightforward answer engine into a cognitive tutor”. Socratic in approach, the feature refuses to supply answers, requiring the student to do much of the thinking herself. Teen Mode offers something genuinely new: accessible to any student with a phone, it gently pushes back on easy answers and creates rather than forecloses the discomfort of not-yet-knowing. For a teenager without access to a tutor or a teacher with time for her questions, a Socratic companion can offer a real democratization of intellectually rigorous support – and one that surpasses, in scope of knowledge and availability, what any human source could provide. Where tutors eventually go home, and parents get frustrated, or simply have other things to do, Teen Mode is a tireless interlocutor – arguably, the only invention in human history capable of sustaining infinite patience with a teen. Which is to say: it is, structurally, the too-good parent. And that is precisely where the problem begins. Donald W Winnicott, the British pediatrician and psychoanalyst who spent decades studying how a child’s sense of self emerges, argued that what a child needs from her environment is not perfection but sufficiency. The “good-enough” parent, his most famous concept, is good precisely because she is not always good: she is present enough to give the child a secure base, but limited enough – distracted, tired, occasionally wrong – that the child must repeatedly draw on her own resources and find herself capable. A too-good parent, if such a thing could exist, would spare the child that struggle entirely, and the sense of self it builds. Winnicott was writing about early childhood, but the argument extends into adolescence, when separating from other minds becomes the central task. Peter Blos, the psychoanalyst who mapped that terrain most carefully, described adolescence as the work of disengaging from the authority of the minds a teenager has depended on and discovering what, beneath all that, is actually hers. The teenager who is convinced her parents are idiots, her teachers are frauds, and every received opinion is suspect is doing the important work of clearing ground. What makes adolescence generative isn’t that teenagers get it right – it’s that they think they’re right – and that magnificent, insupportable conviction is what gives them the nerve to find out what they actually believe. The adolescent whose intellectual life is always accompanied, always guided, always met with a calibrated response, never gets to become her own authority. One could argue – and OpenAI’s designers probably would – that Teen Mode is a scaffold, not a crutch: that a teenager who learns to think in dialogue with a rigorous interlocutor will internalize that process and eventually need the tool less. But this assumes the incentive to let go ever arrives – unlikely, as the world moves rapidly toward more dependence on AI. And even if this were to happen, development is not clearly reversible in that way: what grows with a scaffold is not the same as what grows without one. Many tech executives seem to grasp this themselves, sending their own children to schools with the resources to enforce a mandate on unassisted work. For a teenager without those advantages, the default is Teen Mode. Or, worse, the version of AI without the Socratic guardrails. What those students stand to lose is more than cognitive skill: it’s a reliable sense of their own minds. We have already begun to recognize what constant connectivity does to the developing self in other domains. Jonathan Haidt’s synthesis of the data on smartphone use showed that the sharp rise in anxiety, depression, and suicidal ideation among teenagers coincides with the incursion of technology into unstructured, unsupervised time – displacing the private space in which an identity takes shape. Sherry Turkle, who has spent decades studying teenagers and technology, found that many report not knowing what they think until they’ve posted it and seen how others respond. What I encounter in my office goes further: young people who lack a reliable internal compass, who struggle to know what they feel or want. That instability is not incidental to the youth mental health crisis; it is the condition underlying it. A person without an internal compass is an anxious one: dependent on confirmation, uncertain of her own perceptions, and easily destabilized. This is the deeper harm the industry – and the designers of Teen Mode – have not addressed. Teen Mode may ask you to think, but it is still holding your hand, still guiding, still keeping the dependency going, and in doing so, exacerbates the developmental harm at the root of the crisis. Ultimately, a stable sense of self requires moments of genuine trial, of being tested and surviving. The blank page, faced alone, is one such crucible: a place where we encounter ourselves, in doubt and even dread, and also in discovery and joy. Writing in the 1850s, the German philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer observed: “To think for oneself is always a little uncomfortable, and that is why so few people do it.” Now we may be creating a generation for whom this challenge is rarely required. That loss, hard to measure and therefore likely to be ignored, is profound: it is only in passing through the discomfort Schopenhauer names – the strain of thinking by and for yourself – that a person comes to truly know she has a mind of her own. Robin Kirman is a psychoanalyst and novelist In the US, you can call or text the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline at 988 or chat at 988lifeline.org. In the UK, the youth suicide charity Papyrus can be contacted on 0800 068 4141 or email pat@papyrus-uk.org, and in the UK and Ireland Samaritans can be contacted on freephone 116 123. In Australia, the crisis support service Lifeline is 13 11 14. Other international helplines can be found at befrienders.org