A Stoic SaysA Stoic Says logo - Daily Stoic philosophy and wisdom

November 12, 2026

Trump ran on a platform of peace. His war may have cost Republicans the midterms | Mohamad Bazzi

Thesis: Donald Trump's shift from an anti-war platform to initiating a conflict with Iran has alienated voters and contributed to Republican losses in the midterms.

Stakes: With 74% of voters citing the war as a significant factor in their congressional decisions, Trump's military actions have not only contradicted his "America First" rhetoric but also fueled public discontent over rising energy prices and economic instability.

Takeaway: The midterm elections serve as a stark reminder that voters hold leaders accountable for foreign policy decisions, particularly when those choices betray promises of peace and stability.

Thumbnail for Trump ran on a platform of peace. His war may have cost Republicans the midterms | Mohamad Bazzi

Stoic Response

War & ConflictPolitics & GovernanceEconomy & Labor

Citizens of the Agora,

Today, we gather to reflect on the pivotal choices that shape our nation’s destiny. As we stand at the crossroads of history, we must consider the implications of our leaders’ actions, particularly in matters of war and peace. The recent midterm elections have served as a clarion call, revealing the discontent among the populace regarding the shift from a promised path of diplomacy to the chaos of military conflict, specifically in Iran. This is not merely a political issue; it is a matter of virtue, accountability, and the very essence of our democratic principles.

The cardinal virtues of prudence and justice demand that we hold our leaders accountable for their choices. Donald Trump, who once decried the folly of foreign entanglements, has paradoxically led us into a conflict that has cost us dearly—not only in lives and resources but in the trust of the very citizens he vowed to protect. A staggering 74% of voters indicated that the war was a crucial factor in their midterm decisions, and 63% believed the military actions taken against Iran were misguided. These numbers reflect a profound shift in public sentiment, a rejection of the betrayal of promises made to prioritize peace and stability.

Moreover, the economic ramifications of this conflict cannot be overlooked. Rising energy prices and economic instability have further alienated voters, who feel the weight of these decisions in their daily lives. The strait of Hormuz, through which a fifth of the world’s oil supply flows, has become a theater of conflict rather than a pathway to prosperity. The war has not only contradicted the "America First" rhetoric but has also ignited a fire of public discontent that we must acknowledge and address.

As stewards of our democracy, we are called to embody the virtue of courage. It is time to rise and demand accountability from those who lead us. We must challenge the narrative that accepts war as an inevitable part of our foreign policy. Let us unite in our voices, advocating for a return to diplomacy and a commitment to the principles of non-intervention that resonate with the core values of our nation.

So I charge you, citizens of the Agora: Let your voices be heard! Stand firm in your demand for leaders who prioritize peace over conflict, who value the promises made to you, and who understand that the true measure of a leader is not in the wars they wage but in the peace they cultivate. Together, we can forge a path that honors our virtues and secures a brighter future for all.

Article Rewritten Through Stoic Lens

The Stoic Reflection on Leadership and War

Understanding Control: The Dichotomy of Action

In the realm of politics, as in life, we must discern what lies within our control and what does not. Donald Trump, once a critic of endless wars, chose to engage in conflict with Iran. This decision, though external to him, became a lesson in the consequences of our choices. We cannot control the actions of others, but we can control our responses and judgments about those actions.

The Weight of Promises

Trump's shift from an anti-war stance to initiating conflict serves as a poignant reminder of the importance of integrity in leadership. Voters, reflecting on his promises of peace, expressed their discontent. Herein lies a teaching moment: we must hold ourselves accountable for our commitments. When we stray from our principles, we invite scrutiny and disapproval.

Economic Realities and Public Sentiment

The war's impact on energy prices and economic stability illustrates the interconnectedness of our actions and their repercussions. While we cannot control external economic conditions, we can choose how we respond to them. The Stoic teaches us to remain steadfast and disciplined in our judgments, recognizing that external events do not dictate our inner peace.

The Lessons of Accountability

As we observe the midterm elections, we witness the public's demand for accountability in foreign policy. This is a powerful reminder that our actions resonate beyond our immediate circle. We must strive to act with foresight, understanding that our choices will ultimately be judged by those we serve. In this, we practice the virtue of right action, aligning our deeds with our stated values.

The Illusion of Hubris

Trump's belief in a swift military victory reflects a dangerous hubris, a failure to recognize the complexities of human conflict. As Stoics, we understand that overconfidence can lead to miscalculations. We must cultivate humility and a realistic assessment of our capabilities, remembering that true strength lies in wisdom and restraint.

The Role of Public Opinion

The shifting tides of public opinion remind us that we are not isolated in our decisions. The Stoic must remain aware of the collective sentiment, recognizing that our actions can provoke strong reactions. We cannot control how others perceive us, but we can control our intentions and the clarity of our communication.

Revisiting the Path of Peace

Trump's initial platform as an "America First" candidate emphasized peace, yet his actions contradicted this message. This serves as a vital lesson: consistency between our words and deeds is paramount. We must strive to embody the principles we espouse, ensuring that our actions reflect our commitment to peace and stability.

The Legacy of Leadership

As we reflect on the consequences of the Iran conflict, we recognize the importance of a leader's legacy. The Stoic perspective urges us to consider how our choices will be remembered. We must act with the understanding that our legacies are built on the foundations of our decisions, and we must strive to leave a legacy of wisdom and virtue.

Final Thoughts: The Path Forward

In conclusion, let us embrace the Stoic principles of discipline, judgment, and right action. The events surrounding Trump’s presidency remind us that while we cannot control the external world, we can control our responses and the integrity of our actions. Let us practice these virtues daily, ensuring that we remain steadfast in our commitment to peace and accountability in all our endeavors.

Source Body Text

For much of his political career, Donald Trump ranted at past US presidents who got the US entangled in endless foreign conflicts. He used it as a cudgel to belittle his predecessors, calling George W Bush’s decision to invade Iraq in 2003 “the worst single mistake ever made in the history of our country”. Trump also regularly derided the occupation of Afghanistan as “a total disaster”. Then Trump decided to launch his own disastrous war against Iran eight months ago. And that conflict may well have cost Republicans control of Congress in last week’s midterm elections. In exit polling conducted by NBC News, three-quarters (74%) of voters said the war was a “crucial” or “major” factor in their vote for Congress. And 63% said the Trump administration made “the wrong decision” by taking military action against Iran. The midterms turned out to be a massive public repudiation of the Iran conflict – and of the US legacy of forever wars that followed the terrorist attacks of 11 September 2001. It was no secret that most Americans had soured on foreign interventions and were opposed to Trump starting new ones. In January, a poll by Quinnipiac University found that 70% of voters opposed an attack on Iran – a total reversal from US public opinion ahead of the Iraq invasion more than two decades ago, when polls showed 72% of Americans supported that war in its early days. But Trump was blinded by hubris, thinking he could achieve a quick military victory and overthrow the regime that took power after Iran’s Islamic revolution in 1979. The Iranian regime fought hard for its survival, retaliating against the joint US-Israeli attack by destroying oil pipelines and other energy infrastructure in neighboring Gulf countries, and largely closing the strait of Hormuz. Before the conflict, more than a fifth of the world’s oil and natural gas supplies passed through the crucial waterway each day. The war led to a global increase in energy prices and other costs – and American voters took out their widespread anger at the economic fallout against Trump and his Republican party. It also didn’t help Trump that he ran for and won the presidency in 2024 as an anti-war candidate. He promised to negotiate an end to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and Israel’s war against Gaza, among other conflicts that he argued had been prolonged by his Democratic opponents, Joe Biden and Kamala Harris. “If Kamala wins, only death and destruction await because she is the candidate of endless wars. I am the candidate of peace,” Trump said at a November 2024 rally in Michigan, a swing state he won partly with support from Arab and Muslim American voters. Those voters, many of whom have relatives in the Middle East, were angry at the Biden administration’s unwavering support for Israel as it expanded its war from Gaza into Lebanon and other countries in the region. Beyond his free-wheeling campaign rallies, Trump used his most important speeches to portray himself as an “America First” president who opposes foreign military adventurism. It became a cornerstone of his Maga (Make America Great Again) movement. “I’m not going to start a war. I’m going to stop wars,” Trump declared in his 2024 election night victory speech in Florida. In the end, US voters remembered Trump’s many promises to avoid the same kind of regime-change wars started by his predecessors – and they punished Republicans for Trump breaking those pledges. As the extent of Republican losses in House, Senate and gubernatorial races nationwide became clear last week, JD Vance posted a lengthy statement on Twitter/X blaming the Republican wipeout on the Iran conflict. “The reason we lost is the war,” Vance wrote, explaining that voters who had supported Trump in 2024 showed up in the midterms to vote for Democrats because they were angry about the war, higher prices and other economic fallout. Vance also suggested that the Trump administration had abandoned its “America First” agenda – an attempt by the vice-president to lay his claim as the legitimate heir to the Maga coalition after Trump, who can’t run for re-election in the 2028 presidential race. But the movement may have fractured irreparably, thanks to the Iran war and the devastating Republican losses in the midterms. Let’s not forget that Vance was once a fierce critic of the president, who then cozied up to Trump when it became clear he would be the leading Republican candidate in 2024. In fact, Vance helped promote the narrative to a weary American public that Trump would avoid getting embroiled in new conflicts, unlike his Democratic opponents. In 2023, Vance endorsed Trump by writing a Wall Street Journal opinion article headlined: “Trump’s Best Foreign Policy? Not Starting Any Wars.” “My entire adult lifetime has been shaped by presidents who threw America into unwise wars and failed to win them,” Vance wrote, outlining failed US interventions in Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya and elsewhere. At the time, Vance was auditioning for the role as Trump’s running mate – and his record as a US Marine who served in Iraq, and later turned against the war, made him appealing to Trump’s Maga base. Yet Vance did not dare to publicly break with Trump at the start of the Iran war in late February, when the move would have represented a greater political risk but Vance could have made a bigger difference in the conflict’s trajectory. Today, even Trump is acknowledging that the war played a major role in the Republicans’ midterm losses. When he was asked on 4 November about Vance’s assessment of the election, Trump said: “I think it’s largely true because it drove the gasoline [prices] up a little bit short-term.” But because Trump refuses to publicly admit making any mistake, he continues to defend his catastrophic decision to attack Iran. “If I had to do it again, I’d have to do it again,” Trump added, while touring his half-finished White House ballroom the day after the midterms. “You can’t let Iran have a nuclear weapon.” Of course, Trump never bothered to make a robust case to Americans, or even to Congress, explaining how Iran posed a threat to US interests that would justify launching a new war in the Middle East. Unlike the Bush administration in the lead-up to its invasion of Iraq, Trump didn’t even try to build his case based on lies and manipulated intelligence. And so American voters swiftly punished Trump and his Republican enablers for dragging the US into yet another open-ended war. Mohamad Bazzi is a Guardian US columnist. He is also director of the Center for Near Eastern Studies, and a journalism professor, at New York University