A Stoic SaysA Stoic Says logo - Daily Stoic philosophy and wisdom

November 16, 2026

The Democratic party is at a critical crossroad. Can it do the right thing? | Osita Nwanevu

In his report, Osita Nwanevu examines the Democratic Party's precarious position following significant midterm victories in 2026, reminiscent of the Republican sweep in 2010. He highlights the emergence of new Democratic leaders and a strengthened party infrastructure, yet warns that these gains stem more from voter discontent with the current administration than from confidence in Democratic policies. Nwanevu concludes that Democrats must now focus on a robust agenda addressing systemic issues and material concerns to avoid allowing Republicans to regain power, particularly in the shadow of Donald Trump's lingering influence. The report underscores a critical juncture for the party, emphasizing the need for cohesive messaging and action moving forward.

Thumbnail for The Democratic party is at a critical crossroad. Can it do the right thing? | Osita Nwanevu

Stoic Response

Politics & GovernanceCulture & IdentityJustice & Rights

Citizens of the Agora,

Today, we gather at a pivotal moment in our shared political journey, a time where the echoes of the past resonate with the choices we face. As we reflect on Osita Nwanevu's insightful examination of the Democratic Party's recent midterm victories, we find ourselves at a crossroads reminiscent of the tumultuous year of 2010. Back then, the Republican Party seized control through discontent and division, and now, we see a similar narrative unfolding. The Democratic gains, while significant, are largely rooted in voter frustration with the current administration rather than a resounding endorsement of Democratic ideals.

In the spirit of justice, let us recognize that our political landscape has shifted dramatically. The emergence of new leaders and revitalized infrastructure within the Democratic Party should ignite a flame of hope. For instance, the election of Scott Colom as Mississippi's first Democratic senator since the 1980s signifies a breakthrough, a testament to the power of grassroots mobilization and the collective will of the people. Yet, we must not be lulled into complacency. The path ahead requires a robust agenda that addresses systemic issues and the material concerns of our citizens—an agenda that must be rooted in the virtue of wisdom.

As we stand on this precipice, we must heed the call for courage. The challenges we face are formidable. The specter of Donald Trump's influence looms large, and we must not allow the discontent that fueled our victories to fade into apathy. Instead, let us channel that energy into a cohesive message that not only critiques the failures of the current administration but also articulates a vision for a more equitable society. The stakes are high; we cannot afford to allow the Republicans to regain power, for history has shown us the consequences of such a misstep.

Moreover, let us embrace the virtue of temperance in our actions. The Democratic Party must unify its factions and present a clear, actionable agenda: raising the minimum wage, reforming healthcare, and addressing corruption. These are not mere talking points; they are the lifeblood of our democracy, the very foundation upon which we can build a brighter future. As we move forward, let us ensure that our message resonates with the people, that it speaks to their needs, and that it inspires them to engage in the democratic process.

So, citizens, I charge you today: Stand vigilant and active! Engage in discussions, advocate for policies that uplift the marginalized, and hold our leaders accountable. The future of our democracy rests not only in the hands of elected officials but in the collective will of the people. Let us not squander the victories we have achieved; let us seize this moment to forge a path toward justice, equity, and a more inclusive society. Together, we can shape the narrative of our time—let us rise to the occasion!

Article Rewritten Through Stoic Lens

Lessons from Political Turmoil: A Stoic Perspective

Dear students, let us gather our thoughts on the political landscape, as illuminated by recent events. In the spirit of Stoicism, we will examine the dichotomy of control and transform external events into opportunities for discipline, judgment, and right action.

The Nature of Change

In 2010, the Democratic Party faced a significant setback, a "shellacking" as it was termed. This moment serves as a reminder: we cannot control the outcomes of elections, but we can control our responses to them. Reflect on this: when faced with adversity, do we succumb to despair or rise to the occasion? The Stoic accepts that external events are beyond our control, yet we possess the power to cultivate resilience and wisdom.

Emergence of New Leadership

The recent midterm victories for the Democrats reveal a shift in leadership and energy. While we cannot dictate who leads, we can choose how we support and engage with them. This is an opportunity to practice discernment. Are we aligning ourselves with leaders who embody our values? Let us not be passive observers; instead, actively participate in shaping the discourse and direction of our communities.

Infrastructure and Preparation

The Democratic Party has strengthened its infrastructure, much like a Stoic prepares for life's challenges. We cannot control the political landscape, but we can prepare ourselves for the battles ahead. This is a call to action: fortify your principles and engage in meaningful dialogue. The Stoic understands that preparation is key to navigating uncertainty.

Voter Discontent as a Catalyst

The gains of the Democratic Party stem not from unwavering support but from voter discontent. Recognize that while we cannot control public sentiment, we can influence it through our actions and words. In times of discontent, let us embody the virtues of patience and understanding. Engage with those who disagree, seeking common ground rather than division.

The Challenge of Cohesion

As the party grapples with its identity, we must ask ourselves: how do we maintain cohesion in our own lives? The Stoic teaches us that unity is born from shared values and purpose. In your daily interactions, strive to foster harmony and understanding, even amidst differing opinions. This is the essence of right action.

Addressing Systemic Issues

The call for a robust agenda to tackle systemic issues is a reminder that we cannot control the problems of the world, but we can control our responses to them. Focus on what you can influence: advocate for justice, support those in need, and engage in meaningful activism. Each small action contributes to the greater good.

The Shadow of Influence

The lingering presence of figures like Donald Trump reminds us that we cannot control the past, but we can learn from it. Reflect on the lessons of history; use them to inform your actions today. The Stoic embraces the wisdom of experience, transforming past failures into future successes.

The Path Forward

As we stand at this critical juncture, let us remember that the future is shaped by our choices today. While we cannot predict the outcomes, we can commit to a path of integrity and purpose. Engage with your community, advocate for change, and embody the virtues of Stoicism.

In conclusion, as we navigate the complexities of our political landscape, let us practice discipline, judgment, and right action. Embrace the dichotomy of control, and remember: what lies within your power is the most profound influence of all.

Source Body Text

Until 2026, the most important midterm year of the last quarter-century was very probably 2010. Barack Obama famously called the elections a “shellacking” for the Democratic party and he was right. Thanks to a sluggish economic recovery from the Great Recession and backlash to the passage of the Affordable Care Act, Republicans took control of the House with a 63-seat gain – the largest House sweep since the 1940s – and won six seats in the Senate. But the 2010 midterms were significant well beyond those numbers. It was the first election shaped by the rise of the Tea Party and its blend of rightwing economic populism and xenophobia. Those aligned with the movement lost nearly twice the number of races they won, but the presence of an energized hard-right contingent among Republicans in Congress shaped legislative outcomes for the remainder of Obama’s term and beyond. And a cadre of figures the Tea Party successfully backed that year ⁠— Marco Rubio, Rand Paul, Mike Lee, Ron Johnson, Mick Mulvaney and Kristi Noem – have become key or leading figures in the Republican party in the time since. Just over a month after the new Congress was sworn in, Donald Trump delivered an address to conservative activists and operatives at the Conservative Political Action Conference, where he aligned himself with the stances of Tea Party voters on taxes, trade and Obamacare, and voiced agreement with rightwing conspiracy theories about Obama’s origins that had gained currency within the movement. It was a brief speech from a shameless opportunist, one publicly mulling a vanity run for the presidency he’d decide against within months. But if we’d been paying closer attention, it would have portended much more. A midterm election can alter the trajectory of the parties and the country, sometimes in ways few can predict when the results come in. The larger the swings, the larger and more diffuse the reverberations tend to be. And that makes the work of political prognostication difficult. We will, in all probability, be sussing out the impact of what happened in the 2026 midterms for the rest of our lives – this is as likely if Democrats squander the stunning victories they’ve achieved and offer Republicans a path back to power as it is if the election winds up marking the beginning of the end of the modern Republican party. Both outcomes, and many in between them, seem plausible. What is certain is that the American political landscape, for the next few years at an absolute minimum, has fundamentally changed. For starters, like Republicans after 2010, Democrats have won themselves an infusion of talent and energy atop the raw number of seats they’ve gained. In the Senate alone, a slew of freshmen, from Iowa moderate Josh Turek to Michigan’s progressive rising star Abdul El-Sayed, will be well positioned to help the party shed its gerontocratic image. And some of the election’s largest victories indicate that Democrats have improved and built out the party’s infrastructure in ways that may pay dividends in the years to come. In Mississippi, for instance, quixotic-seeming investments aimed at harnessing angst and anger over the last decade’s regression in voting rights finally paid off with the election of Scott Colom, who will be the first Democratic senator to serve in that state since the 1980s. In Texas, where Democrats have long hoped that demographic shifts would gradually swing elections in their favor, they finally captured not only a long-sought-after Senate seat, but every statewide position on the ballot, including the governorship. “As we sit here today,” Ted Cruz told followers in a solemn post-election video, “I am the only statewide elected Republican who remains in Texas. That’s not something I ever thought I would say.” But, critically, those and Democrats’ other victories were the products less of a confidence in the Democratic party and its vision for the country than – quite similarly to the Republican’s 2010 midterm sweep – of the electorate’s pique towards the present administration and its policies, particularly a war with Iran that has, like the president’s inane tariff regime before it, elevated prices to no good end. In spite of all that, Republicans were barely more unpopular than the Democrats were going into election day, though just about every move the president has made in the time since seems perfectly calibrated to widen the gap. Stephen Miller will now be running the White House as chief of staff; the ideas the administration has floated since that announcement have included going after non-profit groups for supposed terrorist ties, banning pregnant women from entering the country and naming the UFC’s Dana White as press secretary – a joke, Trump claimed, but at whose expense? Those developments have rendered the initial rhetoric Democrats adopted with a remarkable amount of unity immediately after the election a bit awkward. Establishment leaders and progressive stalwarts such as Bernie Sanders signaled a sincere willingness to work with the administration on affordability legislation – atop, of course, the messaging bills Democrats will send the president’s way for an expected veto. But if Miller’s promotion means we can expect more of the same, and worse, from the White House, Democrats will have to spend more time than most seem to want litigating the outrages to come – the impeachment of Pete Hegseth alone will not, and should not, satisfy the Democratic base. The instincts of most Democrats that the party needs to keep a focus on material politics are right, however. Cory Booker said that the new Congress will have to draw out the “real connection between corruption and costs”. Greg Casar, leader of the House’s progressives, has similarly promised to introduce a group of 10 bills “that focuses on costs and healthcare and corruption”. But because Trump is unlikely to enact measures that meaningfully constrain him or hold him accountable for his own malfeasance, the Democrats’ task here is to finally advance an agenda that both indicts him and looks beyond him. They need to present an agenda with the message that Trump’s material and moral failures sit atop systemic failures and tendencies within Republican politics that will follow whoever Trump’s successor as leader of the party happens to be. That is, of course, if the American people dare to give the right another chance at power in the near future. That messaging hasn’t quite coalesced yet, but the factions vying for control of the Democratic party seem to have reached temporary agreement on a loose policy platform for the near to medium term. A higher minimum wage and taxes on the very wealthy, more cracks at major healthcare reform and immigration reform, new regulations to rein in tech and AI, restrictions on foreign aid to rein in Israel – whether party centrists recognize it or not, the left’s organization and advocacy over the last decade brought Democrats to broad agreement on these priorities. The party will have to lean into them all the harder now that Trump, the argument for Democratic governance they’ve come to rely upon, is finally shuffling off the political scene. Or is he? While fears that Trump might seek out a third term now seem especially implausible, he will almost certainly remain a figure of influence on the right after he leaves office. How much influence, exactly, will depend upon how much more damage he manages to do to the country over the next two years, along with the political calculus of Republican business interests, media executives and donors, who may well decide that rightwing populism has outlasted its usefulness. For them, and for all the actors in American politics, including the American people, this is the real point of decision – not election day, even like the one we’ve just had, but this heady, uncertain moment after. Osita Nwanevu is a Guardian US columnist