November 19, 2026
Measles has come raging back in the US. Robert F Kennedy Jr should be impeached | Judith Levine
Headline: Measles has come raging back in the US. Robert F Kennedy Jr should be impeached | Judith Levine
Measles, a vaccine-preventable disease once eradicated in the U.S., has surged back with over 7,700 cases and at least 11 deaths since January 2025, largely due to declining vaccination rates fueled by misinformation. As Secretary of Health and Human Services, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has not only failed to counter this crisis but has actively contributed to the erosion of public trust in vaccines, endangering countless lives. Urgent action is needed, and Kennedy’s impeachment is a necessary step to restore accountability and protect public health.

Stoic Response
Stoic Meditation for Dawn Practice
Author's Claim
Judith Levine argues that Robert F. Kennedy Jr. should be impeached due to his failure to protect public health as Secretary of Health and Human Services, particularly in light of the resurgence of measles, a vaccine-preventable disease. She emphasizes that his actions have contributed to the erosion of public trust in vaccines, resulting in preventable deaths and illnesses.
Weighing Against Nature and Logos
In the Stoic tradition, we must evaluate claims against the principles of nature and logos (reason). Nature teaches us that health is a fundamental aspect of human existence, and vaccines are a means to protect that health. Logos compels us to seek truth and act rationally, especially when lives are at stake.
Levine asserts that “Kennedy seems almost deliberately to have invited fatal childhood diseases back into the US.” This statement reflects a grave moral failing, which contradicts the Stoic virtue of wisdom—acting in accordance with nature and the greater good of society.
Actionable Reflections
-
Embrace Responsibility: As Stoics, we recognize our duty to contribute positively to society. Reflect on how your actions can foster trust and promote public health. Consider advocating for accurate information about vaccines in your community.
-
Seek Truth: Engage critically with information, especially regarding health and safety. Follow the principles of logos by relying on credible sources and scientific consensus. Challenge misinformation in a constructive manner.
-
Cultivate Empathy: Recognize the vulnerability of those affected by health crises. Reflect on the Stoic practice of empathy—understanding the suffering of others can motivate you to act in ways that promote healing and support.
-
Act Decisively: In light of Levine's call for impeachment, consider how you can take action in your own life. Whether it’s voting, participating in community health initiatives, or educating others, recognize that your actions can influence the broader landscape of public health.
-
Focus on the Present: As dawn breaks, remind yourself of the importance of the present moment. Each day is an opportunity to make choices that align with your values and contribute to the collective well-being of society.
Conclusion
In the spirit of Stoicism, let us reflect on the gravity of our responsibilities to one another. The resurgence of preventable diseases is not just a public health issue; it is a moral crisis that calls for informed action, accountability, and a commitment to the truth. As we greet the dawn, let us renew our resolve to act wisely and compassionately in the face of adversity.
Article Rewritten Through Stoic Lens
The Resurgence of Measles in the U.S.: A Stoic Reflection
Introduction
In recent times, the United States has witnessed a troubling resurgence of measles, a disease once eradicated through the diligent application of vaccination. As of January 2025, over 7,700 cases have been reported, resulting in at least 11 fatalities. This situation prompts us to examine the underlying causes and our responses, emphasizing the Stoic virtues of wisdom, courage, justice, and temperance.
Understanding the Situation
Measles is a highly contagious disease that can lead to severe health complications, including pneumonia and permanent damage to the immune system. Despite its preventability through vaccination, the decline in vaccination rates, fueled by misinformation, has led to a resurgence of this disease. The Pan American Health Organization (PAHO) has revoked the U.S.'s measles elimination status, a reflection of the consequences of our collective choices.
The Role of Misinformation
The rise in vaccine skepticism, often rooted in misinformation, has contributed significantly to this public health crisis. It is essential to recognize that while we cannot control the spread of misinformation, we can control our responses to it. The responsibility lies with individuals to seek truth and engage in rational discourse, rather than succumbing to fear and unfounded beliefs.
The Responsibility of Leadership
As Secretary of Health and Human Services, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has been criticized for his handling of this crisis. While it is easy to assign blame, a Stoic approach encourages us to examine the actions and decisions that led to this situation. Kennedy's mixed messages regarding vaccination have contributed to public confusion and distrust.
Examining Cause and Effect
Kennedy’s actions, including the dismissal of experienced advisory committee members and the promotion of vaccine skepticism, have had tangible effects on public health. However, it is crucial to remember that the power to choose how to respond to these actions lies within us. We must advocate for truth and clarity, supporting measures that promote public health and safety.
The Virtue of Justice
Justice demands that we hold our leaders accountable for their actions, particularly when those actions endanger public health. Impeachment may be one avenue for restoring accountability, but it is equally important to foster a culture of responsibility and informed decision-making among the populace.
Courage in Advocacy
We must summon the courage to advocate for vaccination, not only for our own well-being but for the protection of the most vulnerable among us. This includes children and pregnant women, who are disproportionately affected by the resurgence of measles. By promoting vaccination, we exercise our agency and contribute to the common good.
The Path Forward: Temperance and Wisdom
In the face of this crisis, we are called to practice temperance—balancing our responses with rationality rather than emotion. The CDC's recent commitment to investing in vaccination efforts is a step toward rectifying the situation. However, we must remain vigilant, ensuring that our leaders prioritize public health over political agendas.
Conclusion
The resurgence of measles serves as a reminder of the importance of virtue, wisdom, and accountability in public health. While we cannot control the actions of others, we can control our responses and advocate for the truth. Let us embody the Stoic principles of courage, justice, and temperance as we navigate this challenging landscape, ensuring that we protect the health and well-being of our communities.
Source Body Text
At least 11 Americans have died of measles since January 2025 – the month before Robert F Kennedy Jr became secretary of Health and Human Services. One of Friday’s victims was a child, in Wisconsin, where a baby died of measles the week before. Pennsylvania has not disclosed the age of the other person. Measles is a highly contagious but vaccine-preventable disease. It can kill you with pneumonia, leave you deaf, or permanently damage your immune system. The disease was wiped out in the US a quarter-century ago. Yet in less than two years, outbreaks in 47 states have pushed the numbers of illnesses and deaths to levels unseen since 1991. The country has tallied more than 7,700 cases since January 2025, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. The majority of those sickened, hospitalized and killed by measles are under 20 years old; an alarming percentage are not yet five. In the past two years, 112 pregnant women have been hospitalized with complications of measles, until now extraordinarily rare. Two lost their pregnancies. A dozen babies have been born infected. On 17 November, the Pan American Health Organization (Paho) revoked the US’s measles elimination status, which it has held since 2000. Even before that, since the mid-1990s, only a few dozen to a few hundred cases were reported annually, and any small outbreaks were contained within the year, the standard for gaining and keeping the status. Now, says KFF Health News, “measles has re-established regular transmission in the country”. The reason for this scourge is plain: a sliding vaccination rate. The reason for the slide is a growing suspicion of vaccines. That suspicion has been floating around for decades, but for its renewal and spread – as virulent as measles itself – we can thank the misinformation crusade led by the secretary of health and joined by the president. Kennedy is a prolific conspiracy monger: wifi causes “leaky brain”; chemicals in the water turn children transgender. But his premier contribution to American stupidity has been to amplify the fiction that vaccinations cause autism. Reuters called RFK Jr “the nation’s leading anti-vaccine activist”. As the person responsible for safeguarding the health of the American people, Robert F Kennedy Jr is to blame for thousands of preventable cases of severe illness and at least 11 deaths. Almost to a person, these latter-day measles victims were unvaccinated. Kennedy should be impeached. Measles’ revival did not happen because the secretary of health was otherwise engaged, like so many of Trump’s incompetents. Rather, Kennedy seems almost deliberately to have invited fatal childhood diseases back into the US and nursed them to vitality. The virus started spreading in Texas in January 2025, but the secretary has not mobilized the agency’s rumor-quelling mechanisms, or enlisted the help of the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), ordinarily the government’s partner in guiding frightened families through outbreaks. If Kennedy has transmitted any messages, they’re mixed. He disputed being labeled as “anti-vaccine”, and endorsed the measles, mumps, and rubella vaccination as “effective”. Then he claimed it was “not safety tested”. (It is proven safe and effective.) But in June 2025, in what he called “a bold step in restoring public trust” – and a long list of medical associations called the opposite – Kennedy fired all 17 members of the CDC Advisory Committee on Immunizations and packed the vaccine committee with vaccine skeptics. In January, following a presidential executive order full of pseudoscientific poppycock, the CDC released a plan to revise childhood immunization guidelines, both complicating and loosening them. “At a time when parents, pediatricians and the public are looking for clear guidance and accurate information, this ill-considered decision will sow further chaos and confusion and erode confidence in immunizations,” the AAP president, Dr Andrew D Racine, said. The AAP sued, and in March 2026 a federal judge annulled all votes taken by the reconstituted ACIP and ordered a restoration of the pre-Kennedy guidelines. Nevertheless, Trump released another executive order this summer, debuting the anti-immunization committee’s “gold standard” recommendations. The president was keenest on breaking the measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vax into separate shots. The three-in-one was “quite lethal”, he claimed, falsely. Experts say spacing out the immunizations would endanger children. Drugmakers suggest that the product can’t be sliced up anyway. Kennedy has sown distrust in state health departments, long the source of data for the federal agencies. After Pennsylvania reported the deaths of two babies too young to be vaccinated, for instance, he posted without evidence that one of them “may … have been altogether fabricated”. In September, the secretary ordered the CDC director, Erica Schwartz, to remove the two deaths from its publicly accessible data. In late October, Schwartz declined to sign off on an urgent health alert to clinicians encountering measles-related symptoms in pregnant patients that they have not seen in decades, or ever. CDC higher-ups have inexplicably postponed other vaccine-related reports cleared for publication by expert readers. One was a study of infant mortality from whooping cough, or pertussis, which found that the mothers of most of the babies who died did not get a vaccine while pregnant that protects infants, who are most susceptible to severe pertussis. Doctors were miffed. “We don’t have data on this part. The experience is limited,” a Canadian obstetrician told the Washington Post. “When I’m dealing with this situation, I’m dealing with not just Jane who’s pregnant, but the baby or babies inside her womb.” The only conclusion to draw is that HHS doesn’t want us to know that vaccines save lives, and refusing them imperils lives, especially those of the most vulnerable. After Paho withdrew the country’s measles elimination status this week, the CDC announced it would invest $100m to get it back: “We will encourage MMR vaccination, expand access to vaccines, and help communities close gaps in protection. We will equip state, local, tribal, and territorial health departments with tools and technical support to identify communities at increased risk, engage trusted partners, detect cases quickly, and respond effectively to outbreaks,” reads its statement. It’s hard to imagine this plan represents an epiphany for the man who squandered a half-century of public health progress in the first place. This week, the chair of an independent US advisory committee to the Paho betrayed his disgust. “We’ve gotten comfortable letting children be stopped by a deadly disease and die from it,” he said. No, “we” have not. The Trump administration has. It is a cult high on “lethality” and blasé about death, whether in Pennsylvania or Ukraine, Wisconsin or Iran. Kennedy is the cult’s guru. In Indianapolis in April 2025, when more than 800 Americans had already contracted measles and three had died, he praised his staff –and, by implication, his own leadership. The CDC, he said, had “done a very good job containing the measles outbreak”. Trump is the cult’s No 1 apostle. But this is not the first time he has shrugged off the demise of the people he was elected to serve. During the Covid-19 epidemic, Axios asked the president to comment on the 1,000 people who were dying every day from suffocation and organ failure caused by the virus. Replied Trump: “It is what it is.” Judith Levine is a frequent contributor to the Guardian. Her Substack is Today in Fascism